When homeowners compare a cash offer with listing on the open market, the first number they usually look at is the sale price. That is understandable, but it is not enough.
The better comparison is what you are likely to net, how long each option may take, how much cash you need to put into the property first, and how much uncertainty you are willing to accept.
Start with the likely retail sale price
If the house is clean, updated and ready for showings, a traditional listing may produce the highest gross price. If the home needs major work, the realistic retail price may depend on completing repairs or accepting a buyer who expects a discount.
Use realistic comparable sales, not the highest remodeled sale in the neighborhood, when estimating the retail outcome.
Subtract the costs of getting there
Depending on the property and your listing agreement, the retail route may involve some combination of repairs, cleaning, landscaping, staging, seller concessions, agent compensation, title/escrow expenses and holding costs while the property is on the market.
There may also be costs that are hard to put on a spreadsheet: coordinating contractors, repeated showings, inspection negotiations and the risk that a financed buyer cannot close.
What a direct cash offer is trading
A professional cash buyer normally offers less than the property’s fully repaired retail value because the buyer is taking on the repairs, resale costs, holding time and risk. In exchange, the seller may be able to avoid repairs, listing preparation, repeated showings and buyer financing.
That trade can make sense when convenience, speed or certainty matters. It can also be the wrong choice when the house is already retail-ready and the seller has plenty of time.
A simple way to compare the two options
For the listing route, estimate:
- Expected sale price
- Minus repairs and preparation
- Minus commissions/agent compensation
- Minus seller closing costs and concessions
- Minus mortgage, utilities, insurance and taxes during the selling period
Then compare that estimated net with the direct offer and the terms attached to it.
Do not ignore contract strength
Two offers at the same price can be very different. Look at the inspection period, earnest money, financing, appraisal requirements, closing costs, requested concessions and whether the buyer can assign the contract. A high offer with a broad cancellation clause may be less certain than a slightly lower offer with stronger terms.
Our 10 Questions to Ask Any Cash Home Buyer checklist is designed for exactly this comparison.
Use the free worksheet
If the house needs work, use our Repair or Sell As-Is Worksheet to compare the paths. If you also want a direct number from Shrubby, request a cash offer here.
Recent Comments